Skandalakis & Ross, Attorneys at LawSkandalakis & Ross, Attorneys at Law

Home / Blog / You Got a Demand Letter

Civil Litigation

I Got a Demand Letter. Now What?

A demand letter is not a lawsuit, and panic is not a strategy. It is an opening move: part claim, part negotiation, part theater. What you do in the next two weeks, what you preserve, who you notify, and what you put in writing, shapes everything that follows. Here is the playbook from the side that writes these letters for a living.

By Mitch Skandalakis · Skandalakis & Ross · November 18, 2026

What a demand letter is, and is not

It is a private communication asserting a claim and demanding something, usually money, by a date. It is not a court filing, the deadline inside it is the sender’s invention rather than a legal one, and ignoring it does not create a default judgment. What it does signal is that the other side organized their position and spent money on counsel or wants you to think they did. Read it as intelligence: it tells you their theory, their evidence, and often their desperation level.

The two deadlines that are real

First, if the dispute could be covered by any insurance (general liability, professional, employment practices, homeowners, auto), notice to your carrier should happen now; late notice can jeopardize coverage and the defense the policy would have paid for. Second, the moment litigation is reasonably anticipated, Georgia law imposes a duty to preserve relevant evidence: emails, texts, documents, recordings, and data. Suspend auto-deletion and tell anyone involved to preserve. Spoliation sanctions can hurt you worse than the underlying claim.

What not to do

Do not call the other side to "work it out" and make admissions that become exhibits. Do not fire off an emotional response, and do not put your version in writing to anyone but your lawyer; those drafts are discoverable, while communications with counsel are privileged. Do not alter, delete, or "clean up" anything. And do not ignore it entirely: silence is sometimes right, but it should be a chosen strategy, not a hope.

How to actually evaluate it

Three questions decide everything. Is there a real legal claim or just anger in letterhead? What can they actually prove, with documents rather than feelings? And what is the realistic exposure versus the cost of fighting? A litigator answers those in one sitting with the letter and your documents, and the answer sorts every case into one of three buckets: pay or settle cheap, respond and negotiate, or dare them to file. Each bucket has a different first move.

The response, when there is one

A good response letter does limited, precise work: it corrects the record without volunteering your evidence, raises the defenses that change their math (contracts, releases, statutes of limitation, their own breach), and sets the tone for negotiation or war. Sometimes the right response is one paragraph; sometimes it is a counter-demand, because demand letters run both directions and the sender frequently has more exposure than they bothered to check.

If it escalates

Most demand letters never become lawsuits; litigation is expensive for them too, and the letter was often the budget. If a complaint does arrive, Georgia deadlines to answer are short and real, typically 30 days after service, and defenses can be waived by a late or sloppy answer. The file you built in the demand phase, preserved evidence, insurance notice, a disciplined paper trail, is what makes the defense cheap instead of chaotic.

Whether it is bluster or a real threat takes one reading to know. Call Mitch Skandalakis at (770) 693-8715 before you respond to anyone.

This article is general information, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every situation is different; talk to a lawyer about your specific facts.

Common questions.

Do I have to respond to a demand letter in Georgia?

No law requires a response, and sometimes silence is the right strategy. But the decision should follow an evaluation of the claim, your insurance, and your exposure, not avoidance.

Is the deadline in the letter legally binding?

No. It is the sender’s chosen pressure point. The real deadlines are insurance notice, evidence preservation, and, if a lawsuit is later filed and served, the statutory time to answer.

Should I call the person who sent it and work it out?

Rarely, and never before advice. Direct conversations produce admissions and recorded statements. If a business relationship is worth saving, there are ways to negotiate that do not create evidence against you.

Will my insurance cover this?

Possibly, and that is why immediate notice matters: many policies fund the defense, which can be worth more than the indemnity. Late notice is one of the most common ways coverage is lost.

What does it cost to have a lawyer handle a demand letter?

Far less than answering a lawsuit. An evaluation and response is typically limited-scope work with a defined fee, and it frequently ends the matter entirely.

Civil LitigationAbout Mitch SkandalakisIs a Verbal Agreement Binding?Partner Not Contributing?

Elite Lawyers

Demand letter on your desk? Get it read before you respond

Request a consultation

Confidential. No obligation. We respond during business hours, usually the same day.

Corporate and transactional inquiries go directly to Jack Ross. Prefer the phone? Call (770) 891-3681.